November 18, 2026

BBQ or Steakhouse? Comparing Two Southern Classics in Gatlinburg

Key Takeaways:

  • Calhoun’s and Cherokee Grill sit side by side on the Gatlinburg Parkway, so the real choice is the kind of evening your group wants.
  • Calhoun’s is the pick for hickory-smoked ribs, brisket, and a relaxed table that works for groups and kids.
  • Cherokee Grill is the pick for USDA Prime steaks, fresh seafood, and a slower dinner in a mountain lodge setting.
  • Both kitchens are supplied by our own federally inspected butcher shop and bakery back in Knoxville.
  • Free guest parking in Calhoun’s Village takes one of Gatlinburg’s biggest dinner headaches off the table.

After a long day on the trails or the Parkway, most groups in Gatlinburg end up having the same dinner conversation, and it usually comes down to one question: barbecue or a good steak?

Around here, that question is easier to settle than it sounds, because two of our restaurants answer it from the same stretch of the Parkway. Calhoun’s handles the barbecue side and Cherokee Grill handles the steakhouse side, and they share Calhoun’s Village and its free guest parking.

So instead of sorting through every barbecue joint and all the steakhouses in Gatlinburg, this guide puts our two neighbors side by side, so you can match one to the night you’re planning.

Steakhouse Dinner or BBQ in Gatlinburg? Start with the Night You Want

The food matters, but the better question is how much energy your group has left after the day you’ve had, since that’s usually what makes or breaks a vacation dinner. Here’s how we see it:

Choose barbecue when you want a relaxed, come-as-you-are table where everybody orders something different and the kids won’t feel out of place.

Choose the steakhouse when you’d rather slow down, order a cocktail, and let dinner become the main event of the evening.

Calhoun’s in Gatlinburg: Hickory-Smoked BBQ & Award-Winning Ribs

Calhoun’s Gatlinburg is where you go for barbecue the way East Tennessee likes it, with ribs, brisket, and hickory-smoked pork smoked and served in a lodge-style dining room right on the Parkway.

The baby back ribs are the headliner for good reason, since Calhoun’s took them to the National Rib Cook-Off in Ohio and came home with the right to call them Best Ribs in America.

Here’s what we’d steer a first-timer toward on the Calhoun’s menu:

  • Hickory-smoked ribs: order a half rack if you’re saving room for dessert, or a full rack if the hike really took it out of you.
  • Brisket or barbecue pork: both come as a plate or a sandwich, which makes them an easy win for a table that can’t agree.
  • Spinach Maria: the side our regulars tend to order before they’ve even opened the menu.
  • Hickory-smoked prime rib: a Friday and Saturday special that’s worth planning your night around.

Pro tip: Reservations aren’t required at Calhoun’s Gatlinburg location, but they’re recommended, and if your party is larger than eight, give the restaurant a call at (865) 436-4100 so we can have the right table ready.

Cherokee Grill in Gatlinburg: Hand-Cut Steaks & Fresh Seafood

Cherokee Grill is our Gatlinburg steakhouse, and it’s built for the dinner where nobody’s in a hurry, with hand-cut steaks, fresh seafood, and a warm mountain lodge atmosphere just steps from the Ober Mountain Aerial Tramway.

The steaks get the attention they deserve here, because every cut is sourced fresh and hand-prepared at our own commissary before it ever reaches the grill on the Parkway.

On the Cherokee Grill dinner menu, you’ll find:

  • USDA Prime ribeye and New York strip: both are highly marbled 14-ounce cuts for the steak lover at your table.
  • Filet mignon: offered in two sizes, so you can keep it light or go all in after a big day outdoors.
  • Prosperity sirloin: marinated in olive oil, our own Cherokee Red Ale, garlic, and pepper, which gives it a flavor you won’t find anywhere else in town.
  • Fresh seafood: Maryland-style crab cakes, wild Alaskan salmon, and herb-crusted trout for anyone who’d rather skip the steak.
  • Prime rib: slow-roasted on the rotisserie and served on Friday and Saturday nights.

Bonus: Prime rib is the one place these two menus overlap — hickory-smoked at Calhoun’s and slow-turned on the rotisserie at Cherokee Grill. That makes a weekend trip a pretty good excuse to try both!

What the Two Restaurants Share: Our Commissary & Free Parking

It’s fair to put these two side by side because the ribs and the ribeyes start in the same place, a long time before either dining room opens for the evening.

Both kitchens are supplied by our commissary in Knoxville, which is a federally inspected USDA butcher shop and in-house bakery. It’s where we cut our meats, make our sauces (including the award-winning BBQ sauce), and send everything out fresh to our restaurants every day, so neither kitchen is working from frozen, reheated products.

The other thing they share is something every Gatlinburg visitor will appreciate: free guest parking in the Calhoun’s Village lot, so you won’t spend the start of dinner circling the Parkway for a spot!

Planning ahead? If you’re still mapping out meals for your trip, our guide to choosing the right restaurant in Gatlinburg & Pigeon Forge covers the rest of our Smokies restaurant lineup.

So, BBQ or Steakhouse? How to Pick Where to Eat Tonight

If you’re standing in the lot and still haven’t made up your mind, these quick matchups usually settle it.

  • Traveling with kids or a big group: head to Calhoun’s, where the menu is easy to share and the room is used to a lively crowd.
  • Somebody wants ribs and somebody wants a filet: pick either one and don’t sweat it, since you’re parked in the same lot no matter what.
  • Eating back at the cabin instead: order Calhoun’s to go online and carry the barbecue home with you.

Pro tip: If half your group just wants a burger and a beer that’s brewed on-site, Smoky Mountain Brewery Gatlinburg shares the same Parkway address with Calhoun’s.

Come see why life tastes better here!

Whether your group lands on smoked ribs at Calhoun’s or a USDA Prime ribeye at Cherokee Grill, you’re getting a dinner that started in our own kitchens in Knoxville. You’ll also have a parking spot waiting for you when you pull in.

We’ve been a family serving families since 1975, and some of our favorite tables are the ones full of folks who just came down off the mountain hungry!

Ready to pick a table?

*Menu items are subject to change according to season and availability.

Five Stars

Copper News

Select a mailing list (or few) and signup to get monthly specials and more!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Which mailing list(s) do you want to join?*